Barry Hott is a longtime Facebook advertising consultant. He says first reactions to an ad largely determine its performance. He advises merchants to create ugly ads, those that people won’t skip over.
“I’m the Ugly Ads Guy,” he told me.
In our recent conversation, Hott addressed key Facebook ad metrics, budgeting, testing, and, yes, ugly creative. The entire audio of that discussion is embedded below. The transcript is edited for clarity and length.
Eric Brandholz: Who are you?
Barry Hott: I’m a part owner of a performance marketing agency called Adcrate, where we do high-performance ad creative. I also do a lot of consulting through Hott Growth, my own firm. I am a longtime Facebook ad nerd. You might know me as the “Make Ugly Ads” guy.
Brandholz: What can change the performance of an ad?
Hott: I don’t care about cost-per-impression or click-through-rate benchmarks. I’m looking at targeting. Are you allowing the system to target existing customers or recent visitors? Depending on the answer, I’ll look at your data differently.
From a systematic media buying standpoint, it’s about empathizing with the AI, with the machine learning algorithm — understanding how and why it operates in the way it does, how and why it’s incentivized, and how and why it can cheat. The system wants you to spend more money, and it wants to take more credit for more sales.
You can also use third-party attribution tools to help with that. Most people should use one for an extended period to understand how performance tracks outside the platforms.
Brandholz: What’s your take on bid caps on Facebook?
Hott: I have a problem with bid caps on everything and rigid cost caps. That’s not to say I don’t use them. They’re tools to be used in certain ways.
Say an ad is not getting a great cost per purchase, but the system knows it to be getting an overall sales lift. If you set your bid too low or set a cost cap too low, then I fear that the individual ad, if placed in an ad set that has too low of a bid, will never get the chance to spend in a way that it can support the entire ad ecosystem.
I like to have a controlled testing environment where every new concept gets an ad set for organizational purposes and just for letting things battle it out.
Brandholz: What metrics are you looking to hit?
- Top 18 Best Web Hosting Services In 2024: Despite there are multiple web hosting providers available in the market, choosing the best one is really a hard nut to crack!! Because almost all service providers are offering their services with the same features and quality.
- How to start your own Crypto currency website: For a cryptocurrency news website, choosing the right Content Management System (CMS) is crucial for managing content effectively, ensuring security, and providing a great user experience. Here are some of the best CMS options tailored for such a site, each with its unique strengths:
- The Evolution of Coffee Brewing Methods: A Historical Perspective: Coffee has been brewed and enjoyed for centuries, with various methods evolving over time to create the perfect cup of joe. From early methods like the Ibrik method and coffee pots for coffee houses to modern technologies like the AeroPress and Hario V60, the world of coffee brewing has come a long way.
- Stop WordPress from Creating Extra Cropped Image Sizes: Whenever you upload an image to your WordPress site through the media library, it automatically creates and stores multiple additional versions of that image. If your site doesn’t utilize these extra image sizes, they will consume valuable storage space and increase the size of your server backups.
- Explain WordPress Portfolio and how to created them: WordPress portfolios are digital showcases for individuals or businesses to display their work, projects, or professional accomplishments. This feature is particularly useful for creatives, freelancers, and agencies looking to exhibit their skills or services in a visually appealing and organized manner. Portfolios in WordPress can be created using various methods, including themes that come with built-in portfolio functionalities, plugins that add portfolio features, or custom coding for a more personalized approach.
- 15 Essential WordPress Plugins For Every Site: Plugins are essential for every type of website, as they provide additional features and customization options that are not available in the core WordPress platform. A study by CodeinWP found that the average WordPress site has 20 active plugins, indicating the importance of plugins in website development.
- SAILING and YACHTING: Awesome Sailing Vlogs for the Enthusiast
- Comparing Google and Microsoft’s Success in Capitalizing on Generative AI: The buzz of interest in AI services helped drive revenue for Microsoft’s biggest unit, cloud services—up by 7 percentage points compared to a year ago—and Microsoft’s overall sales rose 17 percent to nearly $62 billion. It also gained cloud market share, Nadella added. The number of $100 million cloud deals that Microsoft landed increased 80 percent during the quarter compared to the same period a year ago, and $10 million deals doubled.
- The Best WordPress Hosting Solution in Australia: Each of our WordPress hosting solutions are fine-tuned, blazing fast and are ready for you! Starting a WordPress website has never been easier with our free 1-click WordPress installation, enterprise-grade security and an assortment of tutorials and helpful guides to get you started, all backed by our 99.9% uptime guarantee.
- Elementor vs Beaver Builder: A Comparison of Design Flexibility and Performance in WordPress: Elementor and Beaver Builder are two of the most widely recognized options, each providing distinct features that cater to varying user requirements. This article conducts a comprehensive comparison of these tools, examining their design flexibility, performance metrics, and overall user experience.
- The Best Contact Form Plugins for WordPress to Easily Manage User Inquiries: In an effort to improve user interactions on WordPress websites hosting, the examination of contact form plugins becomes essential. This article aims to present an overview of the top 5 contact form plugins available for WordPress, highlighting their features and pricing structures to facilitate an well-considered choices process.
- What are the 20 best Joomla plugins: Joomla plugins are small, task-specific extensions that enhance or modify the core functionality of a Joomla website. They operate as event-driven scripts, listening for specific “events” triggered by Joomla or its components and executing corresponding actions. Plugins are a crucial part of Joomla’s extensibility, allowing developers to add features or customise behaviour without altering the core Joomla code.
- How to design a strong off-page SEO strategy: Lessons learnt from earning over 50,000 contextual links for thousands of websites in the toughest niches. In 2023, virtually every business that has a website is prioritizing their investment in SEO. The reason being, amidst the chaos of the current year, customers are resorting to online channels for safe purchasing, and optimizing their online presence is a surefire way to gain an edge over rivals. While some firms have set up internal teams, and others have hired external agencies to boost their search engine rankings, a documented off-page SEO strategy is still a rarity among most businesses.
- What are WordPress Plugins? WordPress plugins are modular pieces of software that can be added to a WordPress site to extend or enhance its functionality without modifying the core WordPress code. They allow website owners to add features, improve performance, and customise the behaviour of their websites easily, catering to a wide range of needs, from SEO and security to e-commerce and design enhancements.
Hott: The first thing to do is look at the best ads in the same environment — targeting, attribution, and settings. Everything stays the same. I need to know my best ads can spend this much and get this cost per purchase. And anything in that range is helpful to me. Anything above that, cost-wise, is useless to me significantly. Below that is killer.
I’ll typically have a testing environment excluding all existing customers and some visitors. That could be one-day visitors up to 30 days. It depends on the account and the business. I want to test ads for cold audiences. As an advertiser and media buyer, I aim to make ads that make sense and work for the broadest, coldest audiences. Many people would say that’s stupid, but if it can work well for those people, it will also work well for my warmer audiences.
Brandholz: How much money do you spend until you give up?
Hott: It’s about getting enough useful data. And that depends on what you’re selling — a $100 item or $1,000. Depending on budgets and your return on ad spend, you’re going to have different tolerances. It’s all going to vary. I’m usually looking for about 20 decent signals at the ad set level — hopefully that’s 20 actual purchases. By that point, I’ll know.
I’ll look at an ad that gets shut down quickly by bids for not spending and hypothesize about it. Why did the ad fail? Can I adjust it? I’d rather spend more time obtaining more data to see if there’s another pocket or placement elsewhere. It’s going to lose money, and I’m okay with that. But I will spend the time analyzing it and learning from it from a creative perspective.
However, if you don’t have time to do that sort of analysis, use rigid bids and cost caps.
Brandholz: What sort of creative produces good results?
Hott: Again, I am the Make Ugly Ads guy. I tell people to focus on making stuff uglier because our brains, as marketers, make prettier stuff. What matters are relatability, relevance, and authenticity. You can do that in a non-ugly way. I wouldn’t recommend it. But you can.
That first reaction is often what matters more than anything. Make something immediately relatable that people will care about. Make something people won’t skip. What will make someone feel uncomfortable?
Brandholz: Where can people follow you?
Hott: Go to Adcrate.co or HottGrowth.com. I’m on X (@binghott) and LinkedIn.
